pick the best season

[alpha]

been a while since we've done of these. all from the same year. if you figure it out don't ruin it, try to vote blind.

A: 541AB 47HR 144RBI .314/.368/.643
B: 545AB 49HR 140RBI .303/.392/.628
C: 601AB 36HR 123RBI .358/.414/.631

[eternalreflection]

positions matter

C has best stats

[capable_keL]

A&B are virtually identical

[alpha]

positions matter

C has best stats

I agree, but I didn't want it to be too easy. Maybe I could put up war...
Of, of, shortstop are the positions.

[eternalreflection]

I didn't spend much time thinking about who they were but after the positions got it pretty quick. I had the idea well if it was Carlos Gomez defense in CF vs ok/bad Defense in SS, that B could be the winner and that was more or less exactly what it was. Though given how insanely volatile defensive metrics are, it should go back to C though its pretty close and both are way above A.

yeah probably the worst MVP award of all time, pretty crazy year with 3 9+ WAR seasons