pitchfork's the people's list

[drizzle]

this could be interesting. really curious how the compiled people's list will stack up to pitchfork's official critic picked lists.

http://peopleslist.pitchfork.com/

[LilLeftBrain]

fuck 10.0 i want 108.0
idk crooked rain crooked rain instead

[LilLeftBrain]

just rolling off their list its probably something like

etcetc

[Bones]

prob be a combination of their 90s and 00s list

[Y@k Bollocks]

I started doing this at work, but it's really difficult to think of albums without having all my music to hand. Picked 20 off their list then gave up.

[perfectprism]

^ same, they didn't have half of the shit I wanted to put in my top 10 (U.S christmas - eat the low dogs was at least top 3 for me and it's not even listed). Plus no Sleep represented at all or the stoner/doom movement in general.

[RacquetballGangsta]

added a lot of albums. hard as fuck to edit once all added, so after the top 40, really in no order.

http://peopleslist.pitchfork.com/list/7b59fd40/

[unclebengi]

I had to write in a ton too...no Operation Doomsday, Aquemini, or Wu-Tang Forever? My list was MF DOOM dominated, also had three albums from Built to Spill, two from Outkast, and a couple from MF Grimm. Lonesome Crowded West and Mutations were my only other rock albums. Really hard to do, I realized after the list was done I left off albums like Ironman, Reasonable Doubt, and Firing Squad and felt bad...probably several other albums I'm spacing that should have made my list as well.

[LilLeftBrain]

couldnt even think about doing it the write in way, shit would take forever and putting any effort into it would mean feeling shitty about what you actually forgot

[drizzle]

http://www.pitchfork.com/peopleslist/

lol it's like a parody of itself

[Y@k Bollocks]

Plus no Sleep represented at all or the stoner/doom movement in general.

Yeah - that surprised me, as they do tend to jock Sleep and a lot of those kind of bands.

Oh well. List is nicely done, whatever I think of the rankings.

[perfectprism]

holy shit, what a fucking failure of a result, seriously couldn't contain laughing as I scrolled through

[Matthew]

lol at radiohead and arcade fire making it in the top hip-hop album list

[wheels]

Looks good to me