PF's 2015 NL Cy Young

[Gregg Popabitch]

Make your choice based on your own foundation of evidence.

[alpha]

anyone who votes outside of Greinke, Kershaw, and Arrieta is a complete asshole. Voted Greinke

[Philaflava]

I want Kershaw to win. I think Arrieta or Grienke get it.

[Tommy Bunz]

Kershaw. Partly because he's a historically great pitcher, but also because he's actually having the better season than Arrieta or Greinke if you look at the underlying numbers.
Best WAR (fangraphs version).
First person to post an FIP under 2.00 since Pedro in 1999.
First person to throw 300 strikeouts since Schilling and Randy Johnson in '02.

[alpha]

The underlying numbers... It's still close. Like splitting hairs.

[Joe Pesci]

1) Greinke
2) Arrieta
3) Kershaw

Because Kershaw already has enough CY Young awards

[Kid That's Lifeless]

First person to post an FIP under 2.00 since Pedro in 1999.

He's actually the first to do it since he did last year.

[peanut butter]

Kershaw is gonna get Trouted because the Arrietta story is better.


PEACE

[Myjah]

Zack Greinke

[zappy]

would love to vote for scherzer but he sucked it up too much OH WELL 2 no-hitters dont make up for a lack of consistency

maybe if they had been perfect games. an elbow and an error away from two perfect games.

as for who gets the cy young probably arrietta